something similar to Language Reactor but for Reading

is there something similar to LR that allows you to read on websites/PDFs without having to import first?

I find importing and reading on the platform so monotonous and not as interesting as reading the original website/book

Would appreciate if you could let me know if you know of any product on the market

Hi @Mo880,

There is one that I heard of but didn’t use much called Toucan:

How Toucan Works

Each time you visit a website, Toucan automatically translates certain words and phrases on the page into the language you’re trying to learn. That way, you can learn your new language within the context of one you already know.
------- How Toucan Works Page

It was recommended by some language-learning YouTubers when I was doing a bit of language research back in the day before finding LR.

I don’t think it does pdfs, and as far as I know, it doesn’t color words like LR, but I linked to it above if you want to do some sleuthing of your own and see if it would work for you.


Edit: I recently noticed that DeepL has a feature that allows users to work within web pages and upload documents in other languages to translate.

This is another one I have not had a chance to try, but it seems like it might more closely resemble your request of not having to import first (at least on the web page side of things).


I hope it helps!

Hello fellow noob, I think you’re searching for LingQ here
Learning Languages with Netflix and LingQ - YouTube :3

For LingQ, you would have to import your text before you could work with it, but yes, it’s a good option for reading if you can compromise on the non-importing request you had in your original question.

Additional information about LingQ that may be helpful (from a current LingQ Member):

Free version is limited to 20 “LingQs”

LingQ Forum staff knows this is limiting to users and supposedly they are working to expand this in the future. As of May/June 2023, the free version is still limited to 20 LingQs/words.

Note: LingQs = words saved: Known, Learning, or Ignored (:wastebasket: trash icon)

LingQ isn’t affordable to many users

At 12.99 (USD) per/month or 107.88 (USD) per/year for a basic premium (which goes up from there), it’s still worth it (and different enough in features from LR), it’s just not an accessible price point for most people, especially since I think most shared/LingQ team created isn’t great/necessary, in my opinion.

You have to import text from the source to use any LingQs features for content not already uploaded to their user/LingQ library

Even with the extension, it’s not an “all-in browser” type experience. The LingQ browser extension helps import it into the LingQ website (the same applies to the app if you have the Android/ios app). It does however, have some LingQ-approved/created and user-uploaded content (that doesn’t violate copyright—for shared content only. You can use mostly whatever as long as you don’t share it).

Pro Users can get audio linked to text/source transcript if they upload an audio mp3/mp4 file or have TTS generated for imported text

Generated TTS gets annoying fast on audio-generated content, so I use some random 3rd party resources to download audio mp3s/4s to my computer and then upload it manually to LingQ through the web application. (Note: the TTS in sentence mode for content without audio is a pretty great feature, though.) You can get a transcript/audio with a Youtube video (played by Youtube through their video viewer—not sure how that works precisely—but the way that syncs up with the transcript generated by LingQ (using the cc/subtitles provided by the uploader) doesn’t always sync well if you have to edit the sentence and paragraph formatting in LingQ after importing.

Editing transcripts/texts that are less than perfect can be a pain

Their lesson/sentence editor is still pretty clunky overall, but it’s nice to have the option to edit text! Especially since LingQ automatically formats text/transcripts of imported (manually or through their companion extension) sources/materials. Also, for Korean, I have noticed their text importer is a bit frustrating. It will break sentences at random points and choose to ignore periods in the source text randomly. This is mainly because the edit heavily relies on spaces between text and punctuation: . and ? and ! and other punctuation to break up the text. So, if there is a “(?)” in the middle of a sentence (like in some Korean content), it will likely break the sentence there, even if it requires the rest of the sentence to make sense. (Korean is my Target Language.)

Formatting only seems to transfer through Word Docs but is limited

So you won’t get a "this feels like I am actually reading the book/website/article type experience. From my experience, copying/pasting text over from other sources (like Google Docs) wipes all formatting from the original document. I think you are supposed to use the Chrome extension directly on web pages for the best results.

Sentence translation requires users to manually input translations from an outside source

However, if you want to click on words to get definitions or get a translation for a grouping of about 9 words at a time, LingQ is still useful for that kind of thing. It’s not something Like the LR Text Tool/Reader or DeepL, Glosebe, Reverso, etc. (tried to think of dictionaries that translate sentences across multiple languages :sweat_smile:) that can translate more than a 9 word (give or take) sentence.

Content gets deleted from LingQ if you downgrade your subscription from Premium—unless you pay like 2 (USD) a month for their vacation plan or something

For more research, definitely check out their website and their forum before working too intensely with LingQ. You don’t want all that time investment to go to waste if you try it and aren’t willing to have your work deleted when/if you’re done with LingQ.

Note: Using LingQ and LR together has been helpful for me as a learner. I think the strengths of one application help make up for the shortcomings of another—at least for the learning level I’m at currently.

If anything else comes to mind, I will update this later.

For any Korean Language Learners out there with a similar question,

I just stumbled upon mirinae.io that has an extension (looks like Chrome only for now) that’s supposed to work on any website you’re on.

I’ll come back to this reply with some thoughts when I have the time to try out there 7-day free trial and there downgrade to a free plan after that.

Looks pretty cool from the YouTube introductory vids:

Images with Chrome Extension

image

image

P.S. Some info about their features: https://company.mirinae.io/

Additional Note: LingQ user roosterburton is doing some great stuff with some LingQ-compatible extensions that might be of interest to lost interested in LingQ as a complementary language learning resource to LR:

I mention it because it helps make LingQ a more user-friendly experience than before.

Please ignore this reply, if it’s not helpful to you.

P.S. Responding to my original reply since my original reply is no longer editable (time edit limits for the Forum, I think).

P. P. S. LingQ also has a Lifetime Plan (for one language — one-time payment upfront) that I didn’t know about (so it can help with the cost over time).